An agency gives you experienced people, tools and a view across many accounts for less than the cost of a full-time hire. An in-house specialist gives you someone who knows your business inside out and works on nothing else. For most small and mid-sized businesses, an agency is better value. For large, complex accounts, in-house or a mix of the two often wins.
I've worked on both sides, and neither is automatically better. The right choice depends on your budget, how complex your account is, and whether you have someone internally who can own it. Here's how to decide.
The real cost of an in-house hire
The salary is only the start. On top of it you'll pay employer's National Insurance and pension contributions, recruitment costs, tools such as bid management, reporting and research software, and training to keep up with platforms that change every month. You'll also need cover for holidays and sickness, and a plan for when that person leaves and takes the knowledge with them.
One person also only sees one account. That's a strength for depth, but it means fewer chances to spot what's working elsewhere in your market.
Agency or in-house: side by side
| Agency | In-house | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | A monthly fee, usually well below a salary | Salary plus on-costs, tools and training |
| Experience | Learns from many accounts and sectors | Deep knowledge of one business |
| Time on your account | Shared with other clients | Full time, if it's their only job |
| Tools | Usually included | Paid for separately |
| Cover | Holidays and absence covered | Depends on one person |
| Speed of changes | Depends on the agency | Usually quicker |
| Knowledge of your products | Has to be built and kept up | Built in |
When an agency makes more sense
- Your budget doesn't justify a full-time person. Most small and mid-sized accounts don't need forty hours of management a week.
- You need several channels: Google, Microsoft, Shopping, Meta. One person rarely has deep experience of all of them.
- Results have stalled, and you need someone who's seen the same problem solved elsewhere.
- You want experienced people setting strategy, which is expensive to hire for directly.
When in-house makes more sense
- Your account is very large or complex, with constant changes to products, pricing or offers.
- Paid search is closely tied to other teams, such as merchandising or sales, every day.
- You need very fast changes, for example around stock, launches or live events.
The hybrid option
Many businesses end up with both: someone in-house who owns the relationship and knows the products, and an agency that handles strategy, technical set-up, tracking and specialist channels. It works well when roles are clear, so the two sides aren't making changes over each other's heads.
How to choose an agency well
- Ask who runs your account day to day, and meet them before you sign, not just the salesperson.
- Make sure you own the Google Ads account. It should be in your business's name, with you as an administrator.
- Ask how they'll measure success: leads, sales and cost per acquisition, not clicks and impressions.
- Ask for an audit or roadmap first, so you can judge how they think before committing.
- Check the notice period and what happens to your data if you leave.
For a sense of typical fees, see PPC management costs explained.
Questions about agencies and in-house teams
Can I run Google Ads myself?
Yes, and plenty of small businesses do, especially at low budgets. The risk is that the defaults favour spending: broad matching, automatic settings and recommendations that increase budgets. If you run it yourself, learn to read the search terms report and check your tracking.
When should I hire a PPC agency?
When the budget is big enough that wasted spend costs more than the agency, when results have stalled, or when nobody in-house has the time or expertise to manage it properly.
Can an agency work alongside my in-house team?
Yes. Many businesses keep someone in-house who knows the products and customers, and use an agency for strategy, technical set-up and specialist work. It often gets the best of both.
How do I switch from an agency to in-house, or back?
Make sure the Google Ads account is owned by your business, with full admin access. Then the account and its history stay with you whoever runs it, and switching is just a change of user access.
If you're weighing up the options, take us for a test drive. We'll go through your account and tell you honestly what it needs, whether that's us or not. There's no charge and no obligation. You can also read about our PPC management.